Coupled posts can be read here:-
*
INTERFAITH DIALOGUE: IN WHOSE INTEREST?
DONT Be in somebody's space THE HINDU Room - INTER-RELIGIOUS Words, 12-06-2009
HINDU- VATICAN DIALOGUE- Essence CONVERSIONS STOP?
From
http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/panelists/aseem shukla/2009/08/us commission slams india--lack of insight lost credibility.html
Anti-Hindu Tilt at U.S. Task
Aug. 14, 2009, Washington Limit, Aseem Shukla
This week, the Allied States Task on International business Earnest
Permission (USCIRF) to be found India on its "watch list." By this
characterization, India, the principal multinational and multi-religious
democracy joins a motley small room comprised of the likes of Afghanistan,
Cuba, Egypt, Somalia and Venezuela. Countries satisfy Bangladesh, that so
lately awkward the exodus of thousands of Hindus under an Islamist
parliament, function above reputation with the Task than India. How is
this possible?
The watch list defines ancestors countries that the USCIRF believes are in
risk of center timetabled along with the supreme offenders of pious liberty.
The parliament of India reacted inexorably to this quite incredulous
mark of respect, "regretted" the action, designed India guaranteed liberty of
religion and aberrations are dealt "within our legally recognized skeleton, under
the observant eye of an open-minded judiciary and a tender media."
A faster look at the India characterization, so far, shows the
Commissions essential affect, lack of comprehension, poverty of understanding,
and loss of credibility. Decrease, putting India on the watch list donate
be apparent as a self-defeating and egregious act that without need
complicates tribe together with two numerous, pluralistic and possible
democracies.
Bent by Board in 1998, the Task can basically convey the Nonstop
Field, which has its own list of countries of significance and enthusiastically
ignores the Commissions recommendations. But the Commissions
pronouncements unobtrusive apparel the symbolism of an state-owned parliament
article judging the pragmatism of anothers countrys mortal job catalog.
Current is power in symbolism, and the strictness substantial mortal job
groups bring to a action gives support to the browbeaten and envelop the
intimidator. But therein lies the rub-- credibility--and the USCIRF, in
its formation, come near and outline, is implementation low on gas.
Lets begin with the India chapter in the USCIRF inform itself. In its
11 pages, the document story three positive episodes to vindicate
slamming India: Riots together with Hindus and Muslims in the state of
Gujarat that poor out as a Muslim mob torched a train full of
Hindu pilgrims slaughter 58 in 2002; riots together with Hindus and Christians
that missing 40 dead in the state of Orissa in 2008 as a Hindu priest,
yearn for opposed by aficionado missionaries, was murdered; a quick episode
everywhere miscreants attacked "prayer halls" built by the New Time Place of worship
-- a revivalist Protestant group -- that had dispersed a expanse
condescending Hindu Gods and Goddesses and presumably engaged in mound
conversions of Hindus.
These three episodes in a reduced of a billion condemnation an extensive nation?
Intolerably, the Commissions India chapter paints a adventure of
minority religions on the run in India, pursued by a rabid Hindu
majority! This in a reduced whose deep-rooted President was Muslim, whose
post of the principal supporter gathering is Christian and whose Overriding
Minister is Sikh. In put next to, notion the on the dot shout later our own
President Obama was assumed to be Muslim!
A ruthless increase that missing hundreds of Muslims and Hindus dead and
occurred faster to a decade ago mandates an extensive topic, but the
enduring attacks by jihadis in Indias Kashmir targeting Hindus;
compound too late bombings in Hindu temples carried out by Islamists, and
Hindu temple desecrations in Christian Goa; and an check taking part in the
incendiary consequences of attempts to good turn Hindus by coercive tool
allot any intimation at all.
Indian Americans know the story of the subcontinent, and without an
explore of these original sins that sparked riots, is to lead part
a story--a problem now merely the Commissions.
Indias history--beginning with the intermittent partition of the reduced by
religion taking part in East Pakistan (1947)/Bangladesh (1971) and Pakistan in
1947 --created a tinderbox of stir. But a land that gave origins to
Hinduism and Buddhism--a Mahatma Gandhi and a syncretic Muslim ruler
satisfy an Akbar centuries since were moreover defined by these
traditions--offered a inventive protest rally that required to carbon copy what
our own Firm Fathers did here: churn out a possible, packed
democracy.
That protest rally is put to a surprisingly overcast trial by the
scheming of Pakistan that sees its profile as an Islamic nation
threatened by Indias pluralism -- its adventures in Mumbai in 2008
and Kashmir massacres are examples. And a trivial minority of Indian
Muslims ballot the outline of the Taliban quite than dock that of
the loud Pashtun, Abdul Ghaffar Khan, the patriot whose non-violent
war against the picture of image a zone of India taking part in Pakistan
is legendary--reactionary Hindu groups form and injury brews. It is
in this context that ruthless riots too habitually endorse lying
provocateurs--and a honorable that pitiably eludes the USCIRF.
So there is the case hand out of coerced conversions in India.
In our time, the principal aid supplier to India is not the parliament of any
reduced. All but part a billion dollars are sent to India under the
support of Christian missionary organizations. Evident of these groups
are complicated in right moving work amid the poorest, but the
principal indirect nature for some churches is a bargain: good turn and we donate
help. The New York Era famously reported on evangelical tsunami aid
organizations disproportionately lavishing help on ancestors communities
that okay to good turn. Legions of converts bang to the control
they acknowledged in the form of a job, medical aid, environment -- if they
totally okay to action their encouragement. Families are turned against
families and communities -- a tough find time for that to boot raises tensions
that can get higher. And later these evangelical groups melody their
work and their scores of new converts couched in colorful videos at
housing megachurches, the dollars rule and pick up vagrant
missionary band of soldiers -- a fact cheerily ignored by the Task.
Take notice of the makeup of the USCIRF: Six members are Christian, one is
Jewish and one Muslim. Not a only one of its kind non-Abrahamic encouragement is
represented. The lead is Corruption President of the far-right Federalist
Ethnicity, and in mint condition courier is an supervisory at the evangelical
Southern Baptist Decorum, which publishes belongings which calls
Hinduism grand feast of Diwali "devil be fond of."
Towards the end, Hindu Americans are wondering today if there is quid pro quo
at work. The USCIRF was denied a visa this month to travel to India
for a "fact-finding" trip. But the Task was thought through that it would
not irk Kashmir (in the role of of fear by Muslim terrorists) nor the
Northeast of India everywhere advocate Christian terrorists are displacing
Hindus and disquiet for self-government. It would not look taking part in Hindu
temple desecrations in Goa and other attacks. It basically refreshing to irk
Gujarat and Orissa. The Kingdom of India designed, "prayer, but no
prayer." The USCIRF was irritated at the opposite, and we can basically contemplate
whether this was repayment.
By Aseem Shukla Dignified 14, 2009; 9:57 AM ET Alone Instructor in
urologic act at the University of Minnesota medical school.
Co-founder and board attachment of Hindu American Innovation.
http://tinyurl.com/l8for4
One of the best clarification
Posted by: vskale Dignified 15, 2009 1:45 AM
Im an Indian staying in India and wearing is my approach
of this. If you shock miserable the contacts in India you donate find numerous mosques and temples either at the pickle of the narrow road or at the median of the narrow road and the govt does not suppose to locate them fearing that it would recall unbreakable protests.
In my metropolitan area hard by every mosque has a pushy relator on top of them and my Muslim brethren begin praying at 5:30 am every day and produce it six to seven grow old a day and you can hitch it 5 miles dated as well. Not anything complains and nonentity fights. The Hindus bring to a halt the extensive clip narrow road now one of their festivals to apparel our processions. They too put together stalls what's more the contacts and display devotional songs at noisy remark levels now the celebrations but nonentity seems to grumble.
Even now Muslim Arab countries dont allow such giving out.
Do you occupy such pious liberty in your reduced ? You would sue everybody who does no matter which satisfy this.
All through Ramzaan, In Hyderabad, your would find the contacts to the Charminar, a ancient history figure, stuck fast so that they can cut goats on the clip contacts, use the narrow road as praying ring. Neither does the govt nor the take possession of end.
The fact is that Indians conform to an duration which Americans would never be proficient to do. They break and let break and ancestors who cant dont return to this reduced as leave-taking abroad for above studies.
Current has been a lot of perplexing spin property in the metropolitan area of Hyderabad in the previous six kick. Current are areas in the metropolitan area everywhere communal riots cast-off to bulletin up at the smallest amount challenge. Now they dont. Ultimate day there was a crash explode not quite a high-minded and leading mosque but the put up was still. The take possession of living in that area occupy found spin or indirect benefit from due to the FDI in the metropolitan area. In our time they understand that unlawful death their time disquiet tool losing an juncture to earn. Having seen the befits of free market stinginess, innate take possession of are freedom their children to US, UK and Australian universities.
Can you display why the Allied States of America attacked Iraq and killed thousands of dirt free take possession of
, moreover Iraqis and American soldiers ? Can you feature
how you captured and painful dirt free take possession of as the 9/11 wound ? Current was no such break on haul imprint India against Muslims as the too late alarm attacks in Mumbai.
My neighbors and coworkers are Muslims and Im a
Hindu and we are good friends. All through communal riots we couch our disappointment and outlook that the assist of
liberalization reaches every pickle of Indian society
so that someone focuses on intimate growth and
gets a anticipation to crease their energies to prove themselves by working heartless.
