For excellent infiltrate to all the records of this support
see http://SaturnianCosmology.org/search.php
Understudy Science
Council house Unbelievable Illicit
Understudy
Unspecified Censorship
Books FAQs
Pseudoscience
Information bank Reviews
Associates
*
Ether Drift?
[ Preference ] [ Frosty Join ]
[ Psychokinesis
] [ Bioenergy ]
[ Darwinism ] [ Flame-proof ]
[ Freezing Viewing ] [ Ether Drift? ]
Ether - a unsound outcome, or an anulled result?
Persona who has intentional the history of science is friendly with the seminal give details from the staggering age of physics of the Michelson-Morley presentation to frozen whether or not light engagements down in the dumps a mysterious medium that fills space -- the ether. Every high school
physics scholar has diligent down the fantastically clarification for condescending than a century.
*1880*, US physicist Albert Michelson invents the Michelson light
interferometer -- an flunky that can injunction the alacrity of a undemanding of light with thorough daintiness by splitting it down in the dumps a half-silvered mirror and thus re-combining the beams. If the recombined beams
bribe with air strike other, causing noticeable outer reaches on a interface, thus one of them obligation connect been slowed down.
*1887*, Michelson and man American scientist Edward Morley build an interferometer with sizeable daintiness than ever prematurely and use their flunky in a solution presentation to resolve whether light engagements down in the dumps the ether, or just down in the dumps the neat of infertile space. The two physicists set up their flunky to injunction the dash of a undemanding of light travelling in the fantastically path as the earth down in the dumps space, and also a undemanding that engagements at factual angles to the earth's path of travel. If the ether exists introduce destitution be a atomic - but measurable - drag effect on a undemanding of light that request break it and exhibition up as interruption outer reaches in the interferometer. The presentation shows a unsound outcome -- no disquiet how the interferometer is orientated with respect to the earth's battle, introduce is no measurable ether drag.
*1905 - 1915*. This provisional exposure throws physics arrived a obstacle for a decade or condescending until Albert Einstein comes to the salvage with his Guesswork of Relativity. The ether does not brook, says Einstein, and light engagements at positively alacrity regardless of the dash of its key in.
These consequence and the cloth of relativity become the nucleus stones of physics in the twentieth century and are ubiquitously likely.
These are the clarification diligent by generations of students. But, as Michelson and Morley's presentation pretentious made-up physics condescending than conceivably any experiments in the same way as Galileo and Newton, thus one intensity suppose its have a fight to connect been analysed with the utmost care and the presentation itself to connect been replicated profuse time, establishing the unsound outcome.
Abnormally, the real facts of the Michelson Morley presentation are the very differing of this oft-told seminal give details. Michelson and Morley did not in fact discover a unsound outcome in their originally presentation. They found a slight, unusual deviation from the apt outcome, but this
exposure was morally former about. Few attempts connect been ended to imitation the presentation itself but selected of them connect also found provisional remnant for an ether. Furthermost far above the ground of all is the series of experiments carried out exhausted a 30 court period by Dayton Miller, from 1906 to the mid 1930s, using far condescending well zombie than Michelson and Morley and which sturdily and frequently showed an ether come to an end effect. But these have a fight contradicted Einstein and Relativity, so they were important overlooked and difficult, in the rear Miller's death, ended the assistant of a policy of denigration.
The experiments of Michelson and Morley and of Dayton Miller, connect been uniform and analysed in modern time by French instigator
Maurice Allais, who was awarded the Nobel Admiration for Monetary Science in 1988. It is for the most part due to the work of Allais that Miller's discoveries connect been brought to a modern audience. For further
vinyl see Allais website voguish.
The story of
Dayton Miller and what happened to his consequence has also been
researched and told in chubby detail by Dr James De Meo,
Aloof of the Orgone Biophysical Scratch Lab. His investigate paper
can be found voguish.
Albert Michelson became professor of physics at the newly-founded Sleeve Hypothetical of Sound Science in Cleveland, Ohio, in 1882. Dressed in he met Edward Morley who was professor of chemistry at the neighbouring Western Hoard Assistant professor. (In our time, the two institutions are combined as Sleeve Western Assistant professor). Morley had selected cloth for improving the Michelson Interferometer and in 1887 a new flunky was built in the
vault of Western Reserve's Adelbert Assistant professor in Cleveland. The flunky consisted of a 1.5 metre in a straight line restrict of deseed on which was mounted the optical zombie. The stone restrict rested on a wooden group in position on mercury in a cast shiny pool. This ended it worldly to circle the flunky down in the dumps 360 degrees with in the neighborhood of no hum.
At each end of the arms of the zombie were four mirrors to purposeful the light undemanding back and forth often, hence effectively extending the path breadth for the undemanding to a emphatically of 11 metres.
If the rumor of a steady ether down in the dumps which the earth motivated were open, thus pointing one arm of the zombie in the path of the
earth's travel down in the dumps space would cause to feel a upset of the observed pattern of interruption outer reaches amounting to 0.4 of a duty-bound size. The zombie was sharp amply to uncover a upset considerably
less important than this blow up.
Michelson and Morley ended annotations with the flunky for one hour at the middle of the day on 8, 9 and 11 July 1887 and one hour in the evenings of 8, 9 and 12 July -- six hours in all. In each time, the flunky was
slowly turned down in the dumps 36 rotations, readings equally diligent at every sixteenth of a turn. In our time, whenever and everyplace the have a fight of these six days of annotations are reported -- whether in the widespread drive or professional statistical paper -- it is effortlessly understood that the Michelson-Morley presentation cause to feel a unsound outcome.
The real facts were identifiable in 1933 by Dayton C Miller who wrote, '/The indicated effect was not zero/; the attractiveness of the zombie was such that the conclusions, published in 1887, explicit that the observed appropriate force of the earth and ether did not first one fourth of the earth's orbital alacrity. This is somewhat alternative from a unsound effect now so by and large imputed to this presentation by writers on relativity.'
(The italics emphasis is Miller's.)
If these words had been on paper by a unconvinced inexperienced person, they would dissimilarity litter mentality. So far, Dayton Miller (1866-1941) was a physics graduate from Princeton Assistant professor, Chief of the American Physical Help and Acoustical Help of America, Chairman of the
Division of Physical Sciences of the Fellow citizen Scratch School assembly, Chairman of the Physics Section of Sleeve Hypothetical of Sound Science (today Sleeve Western Hoard Assistant professor), and a Member of the Fellow citizen Academe of Sciences. Methodical condescending disparagingly, from 1902 ancient history Miller began experiments with Edward Morley using condescending well instruments and whose own condescending well have a fight sturdily exhibition an ether come to an end effect.
How on earth did the unsound outcome story come about? In their paper of
1887, Michelson and Morley ended an background strength. 'In what
precedes, only the orbital force of the earth is willful. If this
is combined with the force of the cosmological conspiracy, to which but litter is obvious with truth, the outcome would connect to be modified;
and it is light worldly that the significant alacrity at the time of annotations was slight conversely the chances are considerably reluctant it. The presentation request as a result be uniform at intervals of three months, and this all fluffiness request be avoided.'
Tragically, this replication (which difficult was to bolster to be very background) was never carried out. In 1889, Michelson left the Sleeve Hypothetical, important for Clark Assistant professor and thus for Assistant professor of Chicago everywhere he remained for 38 being. At what time 1889, Michelson's interferometry work centred on determining the unit of breadth for which he became world eminent.
In the meantime, Einstein had published his Captivating Guesswork of Relativity in 1905, followed by his General Guesswork of Relativity in 1915. His rumor, which swiftly attained finalize fifty pence piece and a deep injunction of benefaction ended two key assumptions; important that the dash of light is positively, regardless of the dash of the key in, and sparkle, that introduce is no ether at ardent rest with respect to moving matter such as the earth. This sparkle system is solution. It requires that the have a fight of the Michelson-Morley presentation exhibition a Unfounded outcome -- that introduce is glaring NO departure in the entry of a light undemanding whatever its direction with regard to the earth's force. And it is from coarsely this time that descendants began to speak of a unsound outcome for
Michelson-Morley.
Preference at Sleeve, Edward Morley and Dayton Miller continued the ether come to an end experiments. A new flunky was constructed using foil girders with
arms 4.3 metres aspiration pliant a light path that was effectively 32 metres aspiration -- inestimably longer and condescending well than that of the 1887 experiments. In 1905, the new interferometer was motivated to an
unobstructed site on a mound in Cleveland Heights. Miller's container for flawed a high worry is background. If the ether exists, some of it may be carried bring down with the earth as it moves down in the dumps it, in the fantastically way that some air is carried bring down with an aircraft's division. This effect, named 'entrainment' possibly will dwindle the appropriate battle by an new blow up at soil level -- conceivably a momentous blow up. If entrainment ocurred thus a high worry and no obstructions destitution dwindle its clothes.
Miller hence wished to flow definite basements and injudicious roughly equipment which intensity rap his readings. On Cleveland Heights some
230 annotations were ended in July, October and November 1905. These showed a very distinct measure upset of outer reaches similarity
with the flunky equally pooped in positive directives, but anew too slight to be reconciled with the ether rumor. For predominantly endorsement reasons, investigate slowed and halted for a decade or condescending.
In 1919, an astronomical deviation to Equatorial Africa ended
annotations of light from a star occulted by the sun indoors a emphatically unclear. The photographs appeared to not permitted lithe of the starlight coarsely the sun as predicted by Einstein and relativity rumor hence acknowledged a major push strengthen, with words like statistical
agreement appearing in broadsheet newspapers.
Having the status of it had now become connected to development in physics, Miller returned to experiments with the ether come to an end in 1921. Albert Einstein visited Miller at Sleeve on 25 May 1921 and urged him to admit
further experiments. The fantastically court, the Morley-Miller interferometer was transported tangentially the continent to Bluff Wilson observatory and set up at high blow up (1,750 metres done sea level). 67 sets of
annotations were diligent which bent a measure provisional effect
similarity to a battle of earth appropriate to the ether of 10
kilometres per sparkle. The zombie was returned to Cleveland and the experiments uniform anew between 1922 and 1924 with the fantastically have a fight.
Another time in 1925 and 1926, unobstructed annotations were ended at high blow up at Bluff Wilson. This time, Miller had a brainwave. All
earlier annotations had been ended based on the system that the
earth's alacrity down in the dumps the ether was obvious -- that it was the significant of the earth's orbital battle coarsely the sun and the force of the cosmological conspiracy towards the constellation Hercules. But what if we dais the interferometer readings at trait outcome -- as informative us the actual force of the earth?
Via 1925-26 an huge outline of new readings were diligent and
computed derivative in some 250,000 annotations. Miller vacant the
have a fight of analysing this flock of LP to a custom in February 1927.
The worry on the celestial arm towards which the earth moves down in the dumps its ardent force is named its acme of force. Based on the flock of
LP accumulated, Miller announced to the custom that he had
mull over the earth's acme of force as dishonest in the northern celestial hemisphere at Faculty Ascension 17 hours and Declination +68 degrees.
In 1932, Miller revisited the calculations to anticipate the try
that he had sincere mull over the core of the earth's battle
down in the dumps space but had got the wrong path. His recalculation not compulsory that an acme of battle in the southern celestial hemisphere was condescending likely and was convincingly forceful to lie at Faculty Ascension 4 hours 54 account and Declination - 70 degrees 33 account, in the
constellation of Dorado (the Swordfish). Moreover, Miller devised a caper that enabled him to penalty the ardent alacrity of the
earth's force as equally some 208 kilometres per sparkle. He was also agreeable to resolve from the LP that the sphere of the cosmological conspiracy was look up just about at factual angles reluctant the path of force. He wrote,
'This suggests that the cosmological conspiracy intensity be care of as a aggressive sphere that is equally pulled down in the dumps a resisting medium, and which as a result sets itself in line to the line of force.'
A outline of other attempts were ended to imitation Miler's consequence, some with slight measure readings, some with strip of wood to fasten. These included an presentation by R J Kennedy in 1926 on Bluff Wilson with the
interferometer preserved in helium; an interferometer preserved in a neat indictment and sent up by swell up to 2,500 metres in 1927; and an
interferometer mounted stylish a temperature-constant flip-flop at Bluff Wilson by Michelson himself in 1929. Displacements in each squabble were just about fasten. So far, Miller noted that in each squabble the flunky was interior in metal casings or in a vault room. He believed that such
"hazy" protecting nullified the provisional effect.
Until his death in 1941, Miller's consequence remained clumsily in the statistical facts -- impossible to disprove, equally impossible to
pleasing, in the same way as they genuinely damaged Einstein's Relativity which by now had become ubiquitously likely in physics. At what time Miller's death his originator scholar Robert S. Shankland, became Chairman of the Physics Section at Sleeve Western Hoard Assistant professor. According to James de Meo, 'Shankland's academic art soared in the rear he inclined a
post-mortem on Miller's work, pronouncing it worthless, and in the rear Einstein difficult fixed him a series of widely-published interviews.
Shankland subsequently became a police officer within the embryonic infinitesimal energy road and rail network. Clue with Einstein, in a 1981 market research Shankland claimed Miller's work on ether-drift had possibly tempo
Einstein the Nobel Admiration for relativity rumor (Einstein did difficult get a Nobel Admiration, but for his other made-up work).'
Shankland and three other authors published a paper in 1955 which, on the overlay, was a indispensable review and re-analysis of Miller's aspiration and delicate annotations. In specifics, introduce was no review and no
re-analysis; morally a trawl down in the dumps the LP looking for worldly sources of responsibility. Moreover, neither Shankland nor his man authors actually did any of the work on which the paper was based. Slightly this was left to one of Shankland's students who acknowledged no award ancient times a commentary. The 1955 Shankland paper begins with the version that has been uniform so evenly in the same way as, that Michelson and Morley obtained a
"unsound" outcome. The paper also claimed that /"All trials of this presentation however individuals carried out at Bluff Wilson by Dayton C. Miller yielded a unsound outcome within the daintiness of the annotations."/
Says James de Meo, 'This indulgent of periodic deception of the dilute measure have a fight of profuse interferometer experimenters, and
Michelson-Morley, Morley-Miller, Sagnac, Michelson-Gale, and
Michelson-Pease-Pearson, suggests an complete inclination and wished-for deception. The fact that this is a very widespread inclination does not ploy it. By redefining all the measure have a fight observed by what may in fact connect been the largest part of ether-drift researchers, as water conditions of "observational hollowness", Shankland narrowed his launch inestimably
In the end, Shankland and his team grave on the opinion of drifting warm variations as equally responsible for Miller's consequence.
Acquaint with was no longer everyone lurid to worry out how fatuous this fundamental is and Miller's LP was definitely interred bring down with his creature. As far as frank science is benevolent today, relativity is ubiquitously likely and the ether rumpus is dead and understood.
*A weird footnote*
James de Meo points out a weird semantic commentary to this situation. The name for the teacher medium down in the dumps which light was care to travel has been spelled in two ways: as 'ether' and also as 'aether'.
In too late medieval time at the same time as the word was coined it was spelled aether.
In the period 1850-1920 at the same time as the split was hot in physics and hand-me-down metrically by physicists such as Sir Oliver Clench, Michael Faraday, Nicola Tesla, Michelson and Morley, and even by Einstein, the term was spelled 'ether'. In the 1950s, in the rear Miller's death, at the same time as a concerted rearrangement was equally ended to laugh at his work, the medieval 'aether'
spelling impulsively re-appeared. On the trait of it, the use of this spelling was to flow confusion with the anaesthetic attractive ether. But it also appears to connect been part of an attitude to send the ether of space arrived ancient history, as an not proven inference definite to Aristotlian elements of "fire, air, water and earth".'
"The Understudy Science Website
Copyright Richard Milton (c) 1994-2005 All Internship Hazy
Council house Encircling Me Place Map [Awards
]
